Guinness might be the most iconic St. Patrick’s Day beer, but does it top the list? Total Wine & More — the country's largest independent retailer of alcoholic beverages — tracked the top-selling brews across the U.

“Milk Stout Nitro has long been the craft beer of choice for St. Patrick’s Day,” says Jason Ingram, National Sales Director at Left Hand. “As most of us continue to celebrate holidays a little differently, there’s no better way to bring a taste of our favorite holiday home but with this Dry Irish Stout variation.”